Celebrity Fashion Identity Opinion Trending

Why Trisha Paytas’s Comments about Being Transgender Are Problematic

Why Trisha Paytas’s Comments about Being Transgender Are Problematic
(Photograph: YouTube)

On October 7, YouTuber Trisha Paytas shared what she says is her fact—and upset lots of people within the course of. In a video posted to her YouTube channel and shared on Twitter, Paytas—a 31-year-old who has grow to be well-known for her comedy and mukbang movies (don’t fear, SFW)—Paytas revealed the she is transgender. “I AM TRANSGENDER (FEMALE TO MALE)” Paytas titled the video, alongside a thumbnail that featured the content material creator dressed like Troy Bolton from Excessive Faculty Musical.

Within the 15-minute video, Paytas (who nonetheless makes use of her start identify and feminine pronouns) talks about her gender id and sexuality, telling her followers: “I like guys, however I additionally determine as a man—if that is sensible.” For lots of people within the LGBTQ+ group, it didn’t.

Virtually as quickly as Paytas shared her video to social media, the Twitter-sphere was alight with individuals responding to the YouTuber, calling the video not solely complicated however transphobic, exploitative and significantly dangerous to transgender people and the trans group at giant.

I’m sorry however did Trisha Paytas actually simply makes a video with the thumb nail as her dressed as Troy fucking Bolton popping out as “trans” as a result of she doesn’t put on make up some days, is interested in homosexual males and has extra man associates or did I simply hit my head and am going loopy?!?? pic.twitter.com/8y49n2ecN3

— Kirsty (@kkirstylouise) October 7, 2019

Amongst a number of the feedback made in her video, Paytas stated she additionally identifies as a “drag queen” (which isn’t a gender id) as a result of she likes dressing like a lady. The YouTuber additionally says that whereas she “one thousand per cent” thinks she is transgender, she additionally “one thousand per cent” identifies together with her “pure born gender” and has no plans to transition.

The definition of transgender is somebody whose gender assigned at delivery by a physician doesn’t match their gender id. “I feel gender id and expression in addition to gender dysphoria can look totally different for everybody,” says Tatiana Ferguson, a trans activist and program coordinator at METRAC, of Paytas’s video. However, in line with Ferguson, that doesn’t imply that a few of what the YouTuber says isn’t truly dangerous.

Paytas generalizes and makes *rather a lot* of assumptions

One of many largest points with the video is the best way the YouTube star appears to be generalizing and making assumptions, each about members of the LGBTQ+ group, and herself.

Among the many many generalizations Paytas makes is the concept homosexual males can’t have masculine power and straight males can’t have female power. All through the video, Paytas repeatedly particulars that she is drawn to homosexual males and will get alongside higher with them, as a result of she doesn’t like “masculine power.” A press release like this, whereas seemingly innocuous, is definitely fairly barbed, because it implies that homosexual males can’t be masculine or straight males can’t be female, which reinforces poisonous stereotypes about gender and sexual orientation.

Learn this subsequent: Three Varieties of Guys I’ve Met Courting On-line as a Single Trans Lady

She additionally makes assumptions about her personal trans id, drawing a parallel between her want to not put on make-up on a regular basis and lack of cattiness (a trait she sees in different ladies) as a sign that she have to be trans, telling her followers: “I by no means put on hair and make-up in my day-to-day, I often look loopy. So far as girly-ness goes, I by no means put on make-up, if I’ve obtained zits on my face I simply allow them to go. So I’ve all the time simply associated to guys on that degree.”

Based on Delight.com, statements like these may be extraordinarily dangerous as a result of not solely do they trivialize a really nuanced id, decreasing individuals’s trans id to not eager to placed on make-up or do their hair, additionally they make figuring out as trans look like a selection, and even a solution to being lazy or not wanting to stick to society’s magnificence requirements. I don’t need to brush my hair both, however to say that *that’s* a cause you assume you’re trans? It simply doesn’t add up.

…and equates gender id with sexual choice

One other problem that Ferguson identified is Paytas’s conflation of gender id (an individual’s inner and particular person expertise of gender, which may differ from the gender they’re assigned at delivery) and sexual orientation (an individual’s bodily, romantic and/or emotional attraction to a different individual). Within the video, Paytas says: “I’ve all the time been interested in homosexual guys so I all the time thought I’m homosexual man.”

“Whereas there are some trans males or female-to-male who’re interested in males and a few who determine as homosexual or queer, their gender id isn’t instantly linked to their sexual choice,” Ferguson clarifies.

By Paytas’s logic, as a result of she is interested in males whose sexual orientations are queer, then that should imply that she—in eager to be the item of their want—is a homosexual man. Whereas it might appear complicated, it’s actually not. Trans individuals could be straight, lesbian, homosexual, bisexual, asexual or queer. The gender they’re interested in is totally unbiased of the gender they determine with.

The conflation of id and sexuality is prevalent in terms of  individuals’s assumptions concerning the transgender group. In her 2017 memoir, The Secrets and techniques of My Life, Olympian Caitlyn Jenner touched on the general public obsession together with her intercourse life and companions post-transition. “It hearkens again to this misperception that folks transition due to their sexual wishes,” Jenner wrote on the time. Which isn’t cool.

The video trivializes the expertise of trans individuals and spreads misinformation

Whereas Paytas probably wasn’t meaning to be dangerous together with her video, the very fact is she has an enormous platform—with four.9 million YouTube subscribers—and in response to Maya Henry, a trans activist and Toronto-based YouTuber, addressing her viewers when she might not have been totally knowledgeable about terminology or the nuances of the LGBTQ+ group can truly be fairly harmful.

That is particularly dangerous when the stakes for popping out as trans, or merely present as a trans individual, are so excessive. Proper now, in each the USA and Canada, trans ladies—particularly trans ladies of color—are being murdered at alarming charges.

trisha paytas actually stated she was transgender as a result of she cosplayed troy bolton. can she cease being so disrespectful? trans individuals are actually being killed for being themselves #trishapaytasisoverparty

— mai 🕸 (@finestqirlz) October 7, 2019

“It’s dangerous as a result of lots of people actually wrestle to return out as trans, and other people may be killed for it,” Henry says of Paytas’s video. “She isn’t explaining it correctly, and I really feel that since individuals gained’t take her significantly, they may not take the trans group as critically. So she’s spreading loads of misinformation about what it means to be trans.”

Learn this subsequent: What It’s Actually Wish to Be Younger and Trans in Canada Now

Henry factors to a few of Paytas’s reasoning behind figuring out as transgender for instance of this misinformation. In a single a part of the video, she talks about how she would put on a sports activities bra when she was rising up as a result of she had lopsided breasts.

“She was evaluating that to binding for trans males, the place they bind their chest nearer in order that they expertise much less dysphoria,” Henry says. “She was conflating [those two experiences] although she had justified the very fact she would put on sports activities bras as a result of she was uncomfortable together with her breasts being lopsided, not with the truth that she had breasts in any respect.” For Henry, this conflation, together with feedback Paytas makes about having penis envy, miss the purpose of why individuals transition. “The issues she touches on aren’t related to being trans,” Henry says. “So it makes individuals assume that this might be a part.”

As a content material creator herself who has been documenting her life and transition since 2014, Henry says that whereas she’s acquired immense help from the trans group, it’s at occasions overshadowed by the hate. “It doesn’t matter what you publish, somebody will remark one thing transphobic or discriminatory towards who you’re. And also you cope with that on each video,” she says. “It’s not like you can also make one video about being trans after which everybody forgets about it. It’s who you’re. And in order that’s one thing that I really feel like Trisha doesn’t actually cowl in her video. It’s very totally different being a trans content material creator versus what she’s doing.”

…and comes throughout prefer it’s for clicks

The YouTube star confused in each her preliminary video and a subsequent apology revealed on October eight that popping out as trans isn’t a stunt, nevertheless it’s exhausting to not marvel if it’s for the views. Beneath her first video, Paytas promotes her ongoing tour, “The Heartbreak Tour.” And as Cosmopolitan author Hannah Chambers identified, the repeated use of phrases like “this might be scandalous,” and “it simply sounds so loopy” make it look like she’s making an attempt to be deliberately controversial. To not point out the video’s thumbnail picture, by which the content material creator is dressed as a HSM-era Zac Efron, which Henry says is “clearly for shock worth.”

Report this tweet. Utilizing gender id as click on bait is a privileged act of violence. I’m not gonna stand for it. I don’t care what it’s truly about. The headline and photograph used can’t be critical. Trans individuals are murdered for quietly making an attempt to stay their life. Massive NOPE😡 https://t.co/b7PB99vc5H

— VICKY VOX (@TheVickyVox) October 7, 2019

All of it boils right down to schooling

The factor is, Paytas’s statements almost definitely come from a lack of understanding and never flagrant maliciousness. “She’s making an attempt to say one thing very real,” Henry says of the video, “so I’m making an attempt to be respectful of that. However on the similar time, you take a look at the thumbnail for the video, [and] it’s very clickbait and never respectful to the subject.” Past the thumbnail, Henry says the purpose of the video itself is complicated.

Henry says the title of the video makes it look like Paytas’s intention is obvious—to share with the world that she identifies as a femal-to-male transgender individual. “However within the video, she goes on to say that she doesn’t actually need to transition and that she typically identifies as male and typically identifies as feminine. It may be very deceptive.” For Henry, this forwards and backwards was an indicator that Paytas hadn’t taken the time to teach herself on what it means to be trans. “That’s one of many largest elements within the video being offensive to lots of people within the LGBTQ group and probably dangerous, as a result of she doesn’t actually perceive numerous the stuff that she’s speaking about.”

However, we shouldn’t demonize her

As straightforward because it might be to write down Paytas off, we shouldn’t. “My largest takeaway from [the video] was that she’s confused,” Janelle Villapando, a trans lady and fellow YouTuber says. “She nonetheless has quite a bit to determine.” And no matter how we’d really feel, we even have to understand that that is her expertise.

“Sure, she must be extra knowledgeable,” says Villapando, “as a result of being extra knowledgeable helps you get your level throughout extra successfully; however I additionally don’t assume it’s anybody’s enterprise to stifle anybody’s expression of themselves. I don’t ever need anybody who identifies as trans to should really feel like they’ve to elucidate themselves,” she says.

Learn this subsequent: The First Time I Had Intercourse in My Right Gender

Shifting ahead, Henry says she’d wish to see Paytas work with the transgender group. “It can be good if in a response to this video she sat down with somebody from the group they usually went by way of the video together with her and talked about it and she or he responded to their ideas on it,” Henry suggests.

Ferguson has comparable considering. “As an activist, I consider individuals ought to all the time converse their fact,” she says. “So my options is to do one other video with a selected focus that may centre on her true emotions quite than obscure generalizations.” And that features the finally deceptive title of the video, Ferguson says, pointing to a press release Paytas makes across the 5:45 mark of the video. Speaking concerning the concept of labels, whether or not on gender id or sexuality, Paytas says she’s by no means been a fan with regards to figuring out as “male, feminine, homosexual, straight, bi.” “I don’t know if I might say I’m confused, I might say I’m all of it,” Paytas says. Ferguson says a message like this may have been an excellent title for the video, as it will arrange and point out the video as her *private* (and typically complicated) expertise. “By having a title that’s particular to her expertise she will speak extra brazenly and authentically versus associating herself to a group that she doesn’t inherently really feel part of.”

fbq(‘init’, ‘809871662389618’); // Insert your pixel ID right here.
fbq(‘monitor’, ‘PageView’);

About the author